Ayla Reynolds: Mother of missing toddler screams 'murderer' at ex-boyfriend outside court

By Mandy Oteng 0

  • Trista Reynolds is fighting to find out what happened to 2-year-old Ayla who vanished from her father Justin DiPietro's home in December 2011
  • Ms Reynolds, 25, claims pictures showed there was blood Ayla's car seat, baby doll and her father Justin's sneakers
  • DiPietro appeared in court on Wednesday for allegedly assaulting an ex-girlfriend on July 6 in Maine

By Associated Press

PUBLISHED: 07:50 EST, 26 September 2013 | UPDATED: 09:04 EST, 26 September 2013

0

View
comments

Two days after going public with evidence she said police told her about her missing daughter, Trista Reynolds and her supporters screamed at and chased the girl's father following an unrelated court appearance.

Justin DiPietro on Wednesday pleaded guilty and was sentenced to four days in jail for violating conditions of his release in connection with his July arrest for allegedly assaulting a former girlfriend in Portland.

Prosecutors dropped the assault charge itself, telling the judge that the ex-girlfriend was uncooperative.

Scroll down for video

Public attack: Trista Reynolds follows her ex Justin DiPietro on Wednesday to demand answers about what happened on the night their daughter Ayla disappeared in 2011

Public attack: Trista Reynolds follows her ex Justin DiPietro on Wednesday to demand answers about what happened on the night their daughter Ayla disappeared in 2011

Trista Reynolds, right, and Phoebe DiPietro yell at each other outside the Cumberland County Courthouse on Wednesday in Portland, Maine.

Trista Reynolds, right, and Phoebe DiPietro yell at each other outside the Cumberland County Courthouse on Wednesday in Portland, Maine. Ms Reynolds confronted her ex outside court about her missing daughter Ayla, who disappeared while in his care two year ago

As DiPietro walked out of the Portland courthouse with his lawyer, Trista Reynolds and about a dozen supporters ran after him down a street and through a parking garage.

DiPietro and his court-appointed attorney ducked into the Portland police station where the crowd surrounded them and called him names, including 'murderer,' and shouted 'Where's Ayla?'

DiPietro looked away and stayed composed until he eventually took off running. Reynolds and others gave chase before giving up.

Ayla Reynolds disappeared in December 2011 from the Waterville, Maine home where DiPietro, who had custody of her, was living with his mother.

Her body has not been found and she is presumed dead. Investigators have said they suspect foul play and that DiPietro and others in the house the night before she was reported missing haven't been totally forthcoming.

In hopes of pressuring prosecutors to bring charges against DiPietro, Trista Reynolds for the past two weeks has been releasing details she says police told her about Ayla's blood being found in multiple spots inside the DiPietro home.

DiPietro has said he has no idea what happened to his daughter or who is responsible. He declined to comment on Wednesday outside the courthouse.

Trista Reynolds, 25, pictured this month, holds a photo of her 20-month-old daughter Ayla as she reveals the details of new evidence photos shown to her by police in Westbrook, Maine

Trista Reynolds, 25, pictured this month, holds a photo of her 20-month-old daughter Ayla as she reveals the details of new evidence photos shown to her by police in Westbrook, Maine

Earlier this week, Trista Reynolds released new details from evidence photographs taken in the wake of her daughter's disappearance where she claims blood was spattered on a car seat and baby doll.

In a statement posted online on Monday, Reynolds provided previously unreleased details she said police investigators told her about her daughter's case. Reynolds says she wants the public to appeal to the state attorney general's office to file charges against DiPietro.

Ms Reynolds said in January this year, Maine State Police showed her a slideshow of evidence pictures of blood in different locations at her ex-boyfriend's home.

In a statement posted to websites JusticeForAyla and United4Ayla on Monday, Ms Reynolds claims that Ayla’s blood was found in several rooms inside the house, on the sofa and on the little girl's car seat in DiPietro’s vehicle.

According to Ms Reynolds, droplets were also found on Ayla's princess slippers and smeared across the face of a baby doll she played with. The mother said it looked as if her daughter had tried to wipe away the blood.

Blood was also found on DiPietro's sneakers, according to the statement and on the mattress and sheets in the father's basement bedroom.

Ms Reynolds also alleged that police showed her pictures of blood splashes on the floor and walls.

Fighting for the truth: Trista Reynolds cradles her one-month-old son Anthony as she discusses the disappearance of her daughter Ayla two years ago

Fighting for the truth: Trista Reynolds cradles her one-month-old son Anthony as she discusses the disappearance of her daughter Ayla two years ago

She told BangorDailyNews.com last week: 'After seeing [the evidence], it has started to settle in my mind that Ayla more than likely really is deceased and not coming back. I’m not just able to close my eyes and not see her blood.'

Copies of the photographs or other evidence were not given to Ms Reynolds.

Maine Deputy Attorney General Bill Stokes says decisions on whether to file charges are based on evidence, not public pressure.

Miss Reynolds also has two sons. She gave birth to Anthony last month and has a two-year-old son Raymond.

By revealing details of alleged evidence, Ms Reynolds intends to put pressure on the three people who were at the home when Ayla disappeared on December 17 - her ex-boyfriend Justin, his sister Elisha and Justin's girlfriend Courtney Roberts. 

No one has ever been charged in the case. Justin DiPietro told police that his daughter disappeared during the night.

Miss Reynolds was attending a ten-day rehab program at the time her daughter disappeared.

The mother also claims that police have failed to keep her up-to-date on developments in her daughter's case.

Mom: Ayla, right, was in her father's custody while her mother, Trista Reynolds, left, checked into a 10-day rehab programme

Mom: Ayla, right, was in her father's custody while her mother, Trista Reynolds, left, checked into a 10-day rehab programme

She said that she doesn't know if releasing new information will be detrimental to the case, she told BDN, but she wants to move things forward.

Maine investigators confirmed that they met with Ms Reynolds in January 2013 but re-iterated that they have 'no reaction' to her decision to speak publicly.

The news of the bloodstains last weekend came several days after DiPietro's arrest for violating the conditions of his bail for a different charge. 

DiPietro was charged with the domestic violence assault of his ex-girlfriend Courtney Roberts in July and one of his bail conditions was that he not use or possess alcohol.

Earlier this month he was stopped by traffic police due to his car's expired inspection sticker. The officer discovered alcohol in the car and he was brought in.

dad

Father: Justin DiPietro, left, told cops he last saw Ayla, right, when he put her to bed. He said she was wearing green pyjamas with polka dots and the words ‘Daddy's Princess’ on them

Father and daughter: Ayla's blood was found in the partially finished basement that DiPietro used as his bedroom

Father and daughter: Ayla's blood was found in the partially finished basement that DiPietro used as his bedroom

Ms Reynolds says that police showed her pictures of her daughter's blood that was found in DiPietro's basement, room, and truck.

A sample of the blood showed that the toddler's saliva was mixed with it, leading Ms Reynolds to believe that she suffered. 

Police have not arrested DiPietro because there is no evidence to prove that he was the one who killed his daughter but they have said that they do not think it is reasonable to believe that she is still alive.

Di Pietro has maintained his innocence.

Mystery: Ayla Reynolds, of Waterville, Maine, was reported missing in December 2011 by her father Justin DiPietro, who told police he last saw her when he put her to bed the previous night

Tags: Crime News

leave a comment